The North Shore Inn is located west of Fort Atkinson on Lake Koshkonong. The food is great and reasonable. We stopped this past summer on a lark, just out for a drive, remembered eating there in our youth and early adulthood. It was a nice evening. We had a tasty appetizer at the bar with a cocktail, ordered our meal and when called back, enjoyed a very fine dinner. We were both very pleased. We followed up our dinner with an after dinner drink before heading back home.
The North Shore Inn to us seemed more like a local place than a tourist designation. Most customers seemed to know each other and the staff. Everyone was very friendly. Overall a very nice experience. See their Website for more information.